I noticed that you're posting pictures of the same woman.
But anyway, back on topic. Let's talk about what the OP asked:
What is more important to you guys as far as appearance goes?
Would you prefer to date a girl with a pretty face, but a not so great body?
Or a girl with a great physique but an ugly face?
Some men are OK with dating women who are average in appearance. Those men would most likely be very happy to date a woman whose face is average, but body absolutely killer. Similarly, those men would probably be OK with dating women who have average bodies, but very gorgeous faces.
Your question tries to capture too broad an audience. As an example, consider this question: Gentlemen, which ethnicity do you prefer to date, Asians or Africans?
From men who prefer to date one or the other, a useful answer can be given.
Perhaps a more productive start would be in assessing what kind of men you care to attract, and then look for ways to answer just what those men find attractive.
After all, you probably aren't too interested in knowing what kind of feet a foot fetishist finds attractive if you don't care to attract someone who'll suck on your feet all day, right?